LINKS

 
 
 

 

 

SECRET WINDOW

"It Creeps Me Out When Johnny's Not Playing A Weirdo"
Directed by David Koepp - Written by Stephen King, David Koepp
Starring Johnny Depp, John Turturro, Charles S. Dutton
Distributed by Sony/Columbia - 2004 - 96mins - Rated PG13

Jacob Hall's Review

B

 
Some windows should never be opened...
 
I am probably one of the few filmgoers flocking to this who has actually read the Stephen King novella "Secret Window, Secret Garden," on which this movie is based. Therefore, it had something to live up to. Many giggling little female beings came into the theatre, waiting to see Johnny Depp, the "sexiest man alive." What they got, was Johnny Depp, the actor. One of the best thespians who has ever lived. Who would have gladly gone on unnoticed if "Pirates of the Caribbean" hadn't shot him into stardom. Thank God Depp resents the stardom, because this way, he'll continue to put his heart into every role he performs.

With that said, this movie is NOT PIRATES It is NOT A COMEDY as the many parents and 8 years olds in the theatre apparently thought it was. It is a serious, if rather average, ADULT thriller. Depp stars as Mort Rainey, a novelist who is visited one day by a mysterious man (John Tuturro) who is convinced that Mort stole his story. Naturally, Mort rejects this, but soon finds himself in danger. Because the man is quite insane.

Depp is magnificent as always, as is Turturro, an underrated and wonderful character actor. The impressive cast also includes Charles S. Dutton, who is a very good actor, despite his poor choice in roles ("Gothika" anyone?).

"Secret Window" is faithful to the novella for the most part. It has a few added characters, situations, and a tweaked ending, but none of it really hurts the story. The novella was short and writer/director David Koepp makes the right choices in adaptation. Koepp is one of the most successful screenwriters in Hollywood (he penned "Jurassic Park," "Mission: Impossible," and "Spider-Man") and he does a nice job directing.

That puts the fault for the film's occasional mediocrity on his shoulders. A great thriller requires a grand job directing, not a nice job.

"Secret Window" gave th audience quite a few jumps, a few laughs (obviously humorous improvisations by Depp) and an overall good time. I don't see an Oscar in this film's future, but I see some pleased moviegoers.
 
© Written by Jacob Hall - Email Me!

How We Rated This Film

TC Candler -

D+
Richard Propes - B-
Jacob Hall - B

TC Candler's Comment

n/a

Richard Propes' Comment

This is one of the few semi-successful Stephen King adaptations. Its modest success is due largely to the performance of Depp, who seems to be one of the few actors around who can elevate any film in which he acts. Turturro does a nice job in a role practically tailor made for his personality.


TRJ Enterprises © 2005
Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Contact Us - Legalities


 


ADVERTISING