|
"Rosebud
Schmosebud... This is My
Story!" |
 |
Directed by Orson Welles
- Written by Orson
Welles, Herman
Mankiewicz
Starring Joseph Cotten,
Agnes Moorehead, Ruth
Warrick
Distributed by RKO -
1941 - 113mins - Rated
PG |

So
says the world: "The Greatest Movie Ever Made!"
Over
60 years ago, a small budget was given to radio
prodigy Orson Welles to create his first film,
"Citizen Kane." When it was first released,
audiences didn't "get" it. It was so much
different than anything else made before. It
lost at the Oscars to the sentimental bore "How
Green was my Valley." Now, "Citizen Kane" has
been named the greatest film of all time by the
American Film Institute, and is considered not
only to be a classic, but THE groundbreaking
moment in film.
"Citizen Kane" is the story of Charles Foster
Kane (Welles), a newspaper tycoon and most hated
and the most loved man in America. At the
beginning of the film he dies, but before this
he utters one of the most memorable lines in
film history: "Rosebud."
What is Rosebud? What does it mean? That
assignment is given to a man named Thompson, who
goes on the quest to find out what he can. If
this were any other film made during this time
period, Thompson would be the protagonist. This
is not an ordinary film, though. We never even
see Thompson's face. It is always hidden by
shadow, or off screen. This is Welles' way of
telling us that Thompson may be important, so
he's there, but the focus of the story, so he is
hidden. He interviews a series of Kane's old
friends, and the story is told through
flashbacks: Kane's rise to most powerful man in
America, his ups and downs, and his eventual
fall. Kane is the main character, even if he
dies in the first two minutes of the film.
Welles' genius is only just beginning. If this
was an ordinary film from this time period, Kane
would be a hero, after all, he's the main
character, but he's not a hero, nor is he a
villain. He's not even a true anti-hero. Kane is
the just the protagonist and impossible to
classify. What kind of man is Kane? Is he evil?
Uncaring? Is there a good man located inside of
him? Audiences back then were obviously not
prepared to make this sort of judgment. They had
never seen anything quite like this before.
Nor had they seen Welles' technical expertise.
Watching other films from the period, you can
notice very ineffective cinematography. A still
camera, simply photographing a scene. In
"Citizen Kane," the camera is at angles, it
moves, and it does things never before seen in
cinema. The cinematography becomes a character,
setting tones and moods, sending subliminal
feeling and emotions. The effect is surreal even
today, made even more so by strange lighting,
editing and sets (often built off-scale to
achieve an effect).
"Citizen Kane" is a dark film that proposes many
questions. It is the origin of modern cinema. It
is a masterpiece...with that said, I can easily
say that it is not the best film of all time. I
can say that it is the GREATEST film of all
time, and easily the most influential, but it is
not the most entertaining, or the most thought
provoking (although it comes pretty damn CLOSE
in bother areas).
One must consider this: if not for "Citizen
Kane," the following films would not exist:
"Pulp Fiction," "Fight Club," "The Usual
Suspects," "Goodfellas," "The Shawshank
Redemption," "The Silence of the Lambs," "The
Manchurian Candidate," "The Matrix," and just
about every other of your favorite movies. For
those who still aren't convinced that movies are
art, they should watch "Citizen Kane." For those
little punk kids who refuse to watch anything in
black and white, they should watch "Citizen
Kane." If it wasn't for this movie, you would
not have your favorite films, you would not have
complex, thought-provoking movies that made you
truly, laugh, think and cry. Without "Citizen
Kane," film would still be a novelty, and not an
art form.
As I said above, there are movies I enjoy more
than "Citizen Kane," but I realize that I would
not be enjoying them without it.
©
Written by Jacob Hall
TC Candler's Comment
"Citizen
Kane" is quite simply the most innovative and
influential film of all time. It is fun to
watch, consistently delivering subtle new
moments to me every time I watch it. This
movie is a crash course in filmmaking 101 and
everyone should make a point to watch it at
least three times before they can truly consider
themselves film connoisseurs.
Richard
Propes' Comment
I finally
did my second viewing of "Citizen Kane" this
week as I journeyed through my Top 100
re-assessment. I even had this faint hope it may
become the missing piece to my "#1" puzzle that
was bothering me so much. Alas, while "Citizen
Kane" didn't become my #1 film I do think the
second viewing of this widely acclaimed film did
finally allow to sink in its utter cinematic
greatness.
Charles Foster Kane dies alone in "Xanadu", his
grand estate. In his last breath, he utters the
word "Rosebud." Of course, I've never quite
figured out the logic behind the "dying alone"
and an uttered last word that becomes publicly
known...but, that seems more an advertising
problem than a cinematic one. In the film, a
retrospective of Kane, a reporter is assembling
Kane's life, rise to power and wealth AND
attempting to explain Kane's last word.
In terms of the pure technical aspects of
filmmaking, Orson Welles did it best here. Every
aspect of this film is planned and executed
flawlessly from the physical staging to the
shadows to the music to the performances and the
production design of the film. "Citizen Kane"
is, in many ways, cursed by its acclaim of
greatness. Those who see it now are unlikely to
see defined "greatness," for in our society we
have come to expect huge and grand and epic when
we hear the word greatness. While the man Kane
was all these things, the film itself finds its
greatness in the way it wraps its grandness
around Kane's simplest of desires. "Rosebud"
represents, in many ways, what was actually
unattainable for Kane in his amassing of wealth
and power...the innocence of childhood, the
return to the essence of life. Despite his
strongest efforts to buy his way back into
it...it was to no avail. "Rosebud" was the
essence of Charles Foster Kane, and the beauty
of "Citizen Kane" is in the way Welles' balanced
the epic, larger than life Kane with his quest
for humanity.
Welles himself plays Kane and merited an Oscar
nomination for his performance. It is a
magnificent performance of balance and authority
and yet unbridled compassion in those smaller
moments. The same could be said for Joseph
Cotten as Jedediah and the rest of the
supporting cast. Welles clearly communicated his
vision to the cast...they clearly embraced it
and created a film of power and simplicity.
"Citizen Kane" manifests all the qualities that
today's filmmakers spend millions and millions
of dollars trying to create onscreen. Films like
the LOTR trilogy and Star Wars and Titanic all
have created epic, larger than life films...yet,
perhaps the greatest larger than life film of
all is, in fact, the simple yet masterful
"Citizen Kane."


|